Here’s what the signing of Pete Alonso really means for Coby Mayo’s role

The Baltimore Orioles they overhauled their roster this offseason with a big addition, and questions soon followed. After that signed by Pete Alonsoattention has turned to how the move affects Cobie Mayo and the broader roster prospects as the Orioles look to the 2026 season.

Baltimore committed five years and significant money to Alonso, cementing first base for the foreseeable future. That decision immediately created uncertainty surrounding May, a young bat who has logged extended time in the major leagues over the past two seasons. The organization made it clear that the signing does not close the door on his opportunity.

Matt Weirich of the Baltimore Sun shared President of Baseball Operations Mike Elias’ comments on X (formerly known as Twitter) about how the Orioles handling plan May’s role after the acquisition of Alonso.

Mike Elias says there is still plenty of playing time available for Cobie Mayo, even after signing Pete Alonso.

He indicated that Mayo will see time at first base and DH, and that they are open to “exploring other positions” including a return to third base or the corner outfield.

— Matt Veirich (@BiMattVeirich) December 20, 2025

Elias emphasized flexibility as a guiding principle. Mayo is expected to see time at designated hitter, while remaining an option at first base when matchups allow. The Orioles are also open to expanding his defensive responsibilities as part of their long-term plan.

The 24-year-old’s role now extends beyond one position. Elias confirmed the organization is exploring a return to third base and didn’t rule out potential repeats at corner. That versatility could allow the Orioles to keep Mayo’s bat in the lineup while maximizing Alonso’s presence in the middle of the order.

From a list construction standpoint, the approach signals balance, not displacement. Mayo has experienced inconsistency early in his career, but the front office continues to see his development as a priority. The addition of Alonso brings power and stability, not a directive to replace internal options.

The Orioles believe internal competition will strengthen the lineup. Mayo enters 2026 with a clearer understanding of expectations and a defined path to the bats. By adjusting defensively, Baltimore can deploy a deeper and more flexible offense.

after all, the signing of Alonso reshapes the roles and not the future. For Mayo, the message is clear. The opportunity remains and how he uses it will help determine his place in Baltimore’s plans going forward.