Top 4 options for Browns QB this offseason after losing Deshaun Watson to injury

The Cleveland Browns he came out of the 2024 offseason struggling with uncertainty after a challenging season pushed the franchise into a pivotal moment. With a devoted fan base eager to regain competitiveness, the need for quarterback stability became the team’s top priority. Deshaun Watson’s injury setback added to the urgency. That makes this offseason decision crucial to shaping Cleveland’s future. They have several potential solutions on the table. Now, the Browns must identify a quarterback who can return the team to relevance.

Watson’s injury

The Browns were dealt a major blow when starting quarterback Deshaun Watson underwent surgery to repair a torn right Achilles tendon. Keep in mind that recovery from an Achilles tear generally requires 9-12 months. Watson originally suffered a non-contact injury in Week 7 against the Cincinnati Bengals and was taken off the field. The setback ended his season, marking the second year in a row that his campaign was cut short. The Browns have struggled in his absence. They finished 3-14 for the 2024 season and was last in the NFL in offensive production (253.9 yards per game).

In January, Watson’s rehabilitation hit another hurdle. It has been established he needed additional surgerywhich took place on January 9. With his 2025 season now in doubt, there has been speculation about his future in the league. As Watson’s recovery timeline remains uncertain, the Browns need to address their quarterbacks urgently. They need to secure a reliable starter for the 2025 season.

Here, we take a look at the Cleveland Browns’ top four KB options this offseason after Deshaun Watson’s injury setback.

As things stand

The Browns’ quarterback room currently includes veteran Jameis Winston, second-year Dorian Thompson-Robinson (DTR) and young prospect Bailey Zappa. Of course, Zappe could remain as a developmental option. However, Winston and DTR could be gone soon. This leaves Cleveland without a clear starting quarterback for 2025.

The team could use their No. 2 overall pick or the first selection in the second round of the 2025 NFL Draft to find a solution. On the other hand, acquiring a seasoned veteran can offer more stability.

Draft KB?

The Tennessee Titans hold the top pick in this year’s draft and are reportedly in love with University of Miami quarterback Cam Ward. Assuming no trade changes the draft order, it’s likely the Titans will select Ward first.

The next best quarterback is Shedeur Sanders of Colorado. Opinions differ widely on Sanders’ draft position. Some project him as a top-5 pick, while others put him in the late first or even early second round. Sanders lacks arm strength and athleticism compared to Ward. However, it makes up for it with toughness and resilience. He has shown the ability to stand firm under pressure and play critically. However, timing consistency — hampered in part by Colorado’s inconsistent offensive line — remains an area for growth. This would be another big bet for the Browns.

Super Sam?

Minnesota Vikings quarterback Sam Darnold could headline this offseason free agent market. That is unless the Vikings franchise tags him or extends his contract. Of course, Minnesota’s playoff performance could heavily factor into their decision.

Darnold led the Vikings to a 14-3 season, but his return is not guaranteed. If he becomes available, the Browns should seriously consider pursuing him. At just 27 years old, Darnold offers size, arm strength and mobility. These are the physical tools needed to thrive in the NFL. Yes, he comes with some risk due to past inconsistencies. Having said that, Cleveland’s coaching staff could design a scheme that minimizes his weaknesses and maximizes his strengths. As a bridge back, Darnold gives the Browns a chance to compete right away while keeping their long-term options open.

Veteran Stabilizer?

As an alternative, Kirk Cousins may be a good veteran option. He offers plenty of experience and leadership, though questions remain after a shaky season in 2024. Recovering from an Achilles injury, Cousins ​​was benched after a 7-7 start and threw 18 touchdowns with 16 interceptions. If released by Atlanta, he could sign for a reduced salary. Of course, his decision-making questions and turnovers are a concern. However, Cousins’ record and 159 career starts make him a potential short-term stabilizer for Cleveland.

Trade for…

Although unlikely, the Browns could explore trade options. We expect Geno Smith as the most attractive target on the trading block. Smith’s future with the Seattle Seahawks is uncertain, and his mobility and playmaking ability would fit well in the Browns’ offense. A proven leader, Smith offers a cost-effective solution without compromising long-term flexibility. Again, this is assuming Seattle is open to a deal.

A decisive decision is awaited

The Browns’ quarterback dilemma reflects the franchise’s broader struggle with consistency and success. Whether it’s chasing a promising rookie like Shedeur Sanders, a proven veteran like Sam Darnold or Kirk Cousins, or a replacement for Geno Smith, Cleveland’s decision will shape their future. With Deshaun Watson’s status in doubt, the Browns must act decisively to give their fans renewed hope and a chance for a brighter tomorrow.